Day-to-day Mirror – Lacuna in Legislation Producing Grave Injustice: John Kotelawala ‘Homicide’ Perpetrators Received absent with Impunity


AG’s term on Role of Judges…, and final Friday’s news product on two females aged 24 and 27  currently being killed by their husbands in separate incidents, coincided with past Monday’s post in the Daily Mirror, where he raised a very pertinent issue on the “Crimes devoid of Criminals”, quoting a handful of famous [or infamous?] murder trials listened to in this thrice blessed Island, most of which have been concluded a short while ago, aside from the Kularatne and Sathasivam murder instances the two of which that spanned above earlier 7 decades.

   Attorney Typical Dappula de Livera Pc –in his formal welcome to the recently appointed Supreme Court Judges, declared, “The reliability of a judicial process, in a region, is dependent on the Judges who gentleman it. Judges ought to be individuals of impeccable integrity and unimpeachable independence. A Choose will have to discharge his/her judicial capabilities with large integrity, impartially and mental honesty. …”.
The accused in various situations walked out of the Palace of Justice as totally free males leaving unresolved mysteries for a stunned citizenry to speculate, “…then, who is responsible for killing harmless victims” and for the kith and kin of the murdered to curse the administration of justice in desperation.  Fairness, they say, is the underlying element of the philosophical strategy of Justice.

There had been murder cases where by courts discharged the accused on the advice of the AG for inadequacy or lack of proof.  Is it a ‘lacuna in the law’ that it does not deliver for the victim or the aggrieved bash recourse to justice demanding an acquittal in these kinds of scenarios. Is not it possible to establish  a little something like a ‘special write-up conviction law’, in which authorized rights of an individual  had been denied, could attractiveness for redress or empower the AG to instruct the police to reinitiate contemporary investigations? Public would normally respect clever counsel, an viewpoint that an essential individual offers about what you really should do and how you need to act in a individual circumstance. Like the advice provided by the uncovered AG to high judicial officers a reasonable and different thing to consider of the rights of the distressed get-togethers requirements his attention also. Thought of a victim’s or the kith and kin of the victim’s option to enchantment would improve ‘the pillar’ of democracy. 

In contrast to in the Kularatne and Sathasivam conditions, where by the victims  experienced grave injustices,  a unique predicament occurred  the place an accused was compelled to find the assist of a lethal dose of arson to close his lifetime to prevent struggling with a grueling circumstance of execution, was emerged all through a 115 calendar year old murder trial that aroused substantially general public desire then.  An extract from the manuscript authored by the writer and titled, “Attygalle Murder- 1907 and the Start of UNP” says, 
‘…. the prosecution demanded, when the defending lawyers preserved that John experienced sailed to Japan on a enterprise engagement. A few of weeks later the ship bringing him back again arrived in port of Colombo for the CID sleuth to go on board the ship. John Kotelawala was finding dressed to go ashore when J. H. Daniel, Assistant Superintendent of Police arrested him and took him to the Magistrate’s courtroom for the kin to react promptly, but bail was not granted.

Apart from Col. T. G. Jayewardene, an uncle of JR, and brother-in-law of the two the target Francis Attygalle and suspect Kotalawala, putting strain on authorities from the suspect, the Law enforcement authorities had an axe to grind with him as well. They were being all out to assure the execution of the ex-policemen.  During the demo John dedicated suicide.  The letter tackled to his wife, sister of slain Francis Attygalle he wrote…
April 20, 1907 – My expensive spouse,
I write this to bid you and some others fantastic bye. The case versus me was solid, while I have not instigated any one to murder Francis. All situation sad to say go to verify that I have finished so….. 

I see I have no possibility of escape, authorities and my enemies are determined to see that I am hanged. They are doing all necessarily mean items to obtain that object. ….. Soon after hearing Pila’s proof yesterday, I come across ineffective to assume any hopes. It is excellent for me and anyone who cares for me that I must take this phase beneath the circumstances.  …. A man or woman from Welikada jail has attained the drug from the jail alone.  His name will under no circumstances be stated by me.  Bidding you, young children, dad and mom brothers sisters other relations, good friends and sympathizers excellent-bye and wishing you all contentment.

Your loving husband, -John Kotalawala.
Even a layman who followed the scenario by natural means would concur that there was rarely any dependable proof to conclude Kotalawala’s involvement in the criminal offense.  There experienced been ample testimony in favour of the higher than declare. It occurred in a identical fashion wherever the entire gamut of events involved in the situation, the investigators, forensics, and prosecutors behaved as in Sathasivam’s wife’s murder demo.  Effective mysterious palms prevented, for undisclosed causes, the legal luminaries in the personal bar of the working day, from defending the innocent guy, and forcing them to ‘import’ Indian attorneys.  In 1907, all legal and non-legal participants in the issue joined palms with a widespread goal to assure that John Kotalawala, the father of former Primary Minister [1953-1956] is dispatched to the dying row. They experienced each and every purpose [exclusively personal], albeit any authorized, to do so. Isn’t this ‘culpable homicide not amounting to murder’ exactly where the culprits received away with impunity?

Aiding and abetting is a authorized dogma linked to the obligation of a person who aids, encourages, or incite a further in committing a crime or in another’s suicide. The law, it is reported exists in a variety of distinctive countries and lets a court docket to pronounce 1 guilty of aiding and abetting even if they are not immediate offenders.

Though in Attygalle’s there was noticeable force brought from Kotalawala by them, in Sathasivam’s, the defence was able to generate a acceptable question served by forensic intricacies in favour the accused although clear manipulations by legislation enforcement authorities outside court in defence of internationally acclaimed cricketer, turned apparent in both equally: The assailant went Scot absolutely free in this article while, it was a gripping and a unhappy tale loaded with drama, intrigue and appreciate. Did the accused trampled the throat of the spouse by stamping his shod foot on it following remaining strangled and respiration her final on the flooring of their bedroom as testified by the domestic? 

  Why isn’t there a treatment in statute for the liked types of a suspect who had been constrained to conclusion his daily life in this startling manner or for the kith and kin of an harmless sufferer in a murder circumstance exactly where the accused go Scott cost-free, to appeal for, or find redress at a bigger forum? Community recognition of the judiciary and their self confidence is essential for the sustenance of rule of law.  The impunity of officials in lawful establishments liable for legal rights violations weakens the rule of regulation: they have to not be above the law. Citizens’ self-confidence in the administration of justice is dependent not only on the autonomy and integrity of the judicial officer, but on administration’s mind-set and skill to address the difficulties lifted above. The legislators have a moral responsibility in formulating these kinds of rules. 

Around to you, young 
Minister of Justice!
Author can be contacted on – [email protected]